The consultation, launched in late 2025, invited discussion on whether the diocese should continue its longstanding practice of standing during the Eucharistic Prayer or move to the more common practice of kneeling. Introducing the process, Bishop John noted that “as Catholics, we pray with our bodies,” and that posture and gesture have particular significance at Mass. Parishes were asked to convene local gatherings to explore the issue as part of a synodal approach to listening and discernment.

Participants were encouraged to consider a range of factors, including the Church’s liturgical guidance in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, the wishes of previous bishops, and the current situation in their parish communities. Submissions were invited from individuals and groups, with the process closing on Easter Sunday, 5 April.

Speaking after the close of submissions, Bishop John said the diocese had received over 170 responses and described the level of engagement as encouraging. He stressed, however, that the volume and depth of feedback means the next stage will not be rushed. “I’m certainly not going to rush the analysis of what people have had to say,” he said, adding that he plans to read every submission.

He indicated that any outcome would be communicated pastorally, describing it as not a “harsh decree,” but an articulation of where the diocese is heading now. He also noted that discernment would not rest with him alone. One possibility raised was a further synodal-style process, involving a small group who would “get together and pray and think about it,” as part of reflecting on the themes emerging from the submissions.

Bishop John also highlighted the breadth of voices that had contributed, including young people. As one example, he referred to a submission from a group of students at Sacred Heart Girls College in New Plymouth, whom he later visited to thank personally.

Practical and pastoral considerations were also acknowledged. Bishop John said he would not ask people to do “anything that’s beyond them physically,” noting that the Church is clear that those who cannot kneel are not obliged to do so.

A summary of the themes arising from the consultation is expected once the submissions have been fully reviewed. Further communication will outline any next steps and how any proposed direction would be implemented across the diocese.